C
CoolShitGift Guide
Guides

Funny Secret Santa Gifts That Beat Another Scented Candle

You drew a name. You have no idea who they are. This is the list.

Updated November 17, 2026·11 picks·Contains affiliate links

Secret Santa has a structural problem: you are usually assigned someone you know just well enough to feel bad about getting it wrong. The result is an annual global surplus of scented candles, novelty socks, and desk plants nobody asked for.

The way out is to stop trying to guess someone's taste and instead pick something so specific and strange that it can't be read as a lazy default. A gift that is obviously weird signals effort in a way that a safe gift never does, even when it cost the same.

These are all in the $8–$20 range that most Secret Santa pools use, and none of them require knowing anything about the recipient beyond the fact that they are a person.

How we picked

Selected for being giftable to a near-stranger: no sizing, no taste assumptions, no personal references. Everything is under $20 and reads as deliberate rather than last-minute.

Chicken Soup Candy Canes
1. Best companion to the ketchup canes

Chicken Soup Candy Canes

$9.50via Archie McPhee

Six yellow-and-white candy canes flavoured like chicken soup, from the same company as the ketchup canes already on this list. The joke is the flavour, the wrapping is already festive, and the box is small enough to hide inside a larger gift.

Pickle Candy Canes
2. Best dill-flavoured Christmas

Pickle Candy Canes

$9.50via Archie McPhee

Green-and-white candy canes that taste of dill pickle, boxed with a Santa-hat pickle on the front. It sits next to ordinary candy canes and only reveals itself when someone takes a bite, which is the correct structure for a Secret Santa.

Capybara Air Freshener
3. Best small commitment

Capybara Air Freshener

$7.95via Amazon

A cardstock air freshener shaped like a capybara with an orange on its head, orange-scented, with a string for hanging. Capybaras are the animal people already send each other. This is that joke in a form that fits in an envelope.

Instant Audience
4. Best desk noisemaker under $15

Instant Audience

$11.96via Amazon

A pocket button box with four sounds: applause, crickets, a rimshot, and booing. It is the gift for the person whose jokes die in meetings. Three LR44 batteries come in the package, so it works the morning they unwrap it.

Ketchup Candy Canes
5. Best seasonal horror

Ketchup Candy Canes

$8.37via Amazon

Candy canes that taste of ketchup. It is the perfect Secret Santa object because it is festive, cheap, and actively unpleasant — the recipient will make everyone else in the office try one, which is more entertainment than a candle has ever provided.

Inflatable Unicorn Horn for Cats
6. Best for anyone with a cat

Inflatable Unicorn Horn for Cats

$7.98via Amazon

A small inflatable unicorn horn that straps onto a cat. The cat will hate it for eleven seconds, which is exactly long enough for a photograph. If you know one single fact about your recipient and that fact is 'has a cat', this is the correct choice.

Bacon Bandages
7. Best genuinely useful joke

Bacon Bandages

$9.99via Amazon

Adhesive bandages printed to look like strips of bacon. They function perfectly well as bandages, which means this gift gets used up rather than stored — a quiet virtue in a category full of things that become clutter.

Glow-in-the-Dark Itty Bitty Celery
8. Best tiny gift

Glow-in-the-Dark Itty Bitty Celery

$8.75via Amazon

Miniature celery stalks that glow in the dark. There is no reason for this product to exist and that is precisely the appeal. Small enough to hide in a stocking, strange enough to be remembered.

Cow Print Bucket Hat with Horns
9. Best wearable

Cow Print Bucket Hat with Horns

$12.98via Amazon

A cow-print bucket hat with horns attached. One-size wearables are the only clothing you can safely give a near-stranger, and this one is ridiculous enough that it will actually get worn ironically rather than quietly binned.

Squishy Bun Mystery Dumpling
10. Best blind-box

Squishy Bun Mystery Dumpling

$16.98via Amazon

A blind-box plush bao bun in a little steamer basket, with a rare rainbow one hidden in the run. The unwrapping has two stages — the gift, then the reveal of which one you got — which is more moment than most small gifts manage.

Tony Moly Tako Octopus Pore Stick
11. Best for the skincare person

Tony Moly Tako Octopus Pore Stick

$12.50via Amazon

An octopus-shaped cleansing stick that's a real, well-reviewed skincare product underneath the packaging. Rare in this category: a joke gift that the recipient will genuinely finish using.

Frequently asked

How much do people usually spend on Secret Santa?

Most workplace pools set $10, $15, or $20 as the cap. Everything on this list is under $20, and most items sit between $7 and $17, so you have room to stay under any of those limits.

What do you get someone you don't know for Secret Santa?

Avoid anything requiring size, taste, or personal knowledge — that means no clothing that has to fit, no scents, no books. Absurd objects work best because they signal effort without pretending to know the person.

Are funny gifts appropriate for a work Secret Santa?

Yes, and they generally outperform sincere ones, provided the humour is absurd rather than personal. A yodeling pickle is safe; anything commenting on a colleague's habits, appearance, or personal life is not.

What's the best last-minute Secret Santa gift?

Something small, cheap, and self-explanatory — the capybara air freshener, the mystery dumpling squishy, the pickle candy canes, or the bacon bandages. All read as a deliberate choice rather than a panic buy, which is the whole trick.

CoolShit earns a commission on some links in this guide, at no extra cost to you. That never determines what makes a list — see our affiliate disclosure. Prices are those we recorded when the guide was last updated and can change at the merchant.
Know someone who needs this list?

✉️ Get the Weekly Digest

5 weird, viral, or genuinely awesome products in your inbox every Friday. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

More guides